James Egan Holmes and My Black Bloc story

Like most of us ‘Muhricans, I’ve been transfixed by the events in Aurora, Colorado. James Egan Holmes was arraigned this morning for the crime of turning a movie theater into a shooting gallery. The memes floating about this AM about this story are many. Apparently one can arm oneself with 6,500 rounds of ammunition online, a day’s ammo supply for the average infantry platoon in Afghanistan. Never mind the assault rifle based AR15 he was able to arm himself with (side note–good thing he armed himself with a jam-prone m16 semi-automatic clone. If he’d had an AK 47, he could’ve avoided that pesky jamming problem and continued shooting).

But I suspect the coming weeks and months will find more and more people trying to understand the motives of James Holmes. And the Right wing noise machine has already started.  Over the weekend various right-wing bloggers tried to make a connection between Holmes and the Occupy Wall Street movement. A lot of people are making noise about Holmes being a ‘Black Bloc’ member. I’m trying to illuminate some things here, so let me inject some history.

Black Bloc started in the 1980′s as a tactical response–a means of defending people who were engaged in nonviolent protest from violent police encounters. Police violence against protesters in Germany lead to the formation of Black Bloc groups. These were never formal groups, but arose as the violent vanguard of protesters with genuine grievances. Black bloc participants wore dark clothing and some kind of mask or scarf in order to obscure their identities. While this made it harder for participants to be identified, it also meant that provocateurs could easily infiltrate protests and set up protesters for arrest (or incite violence sure to be filmed by compliant media and used as justification for crackdowns).

I first became aware of Black Bloc when I was writing about the anti-nuclear protests of the 1980′s. Those protests took on a different character in Europe because the anti-nuclear weapons movement was also tied up with other anarchist movements including squatting (setting up living space in abandoned buildings) and other activities foreign to the US. In Germany, the Black Bloc was able to fight the authorities to the point where in some cases, squatters got rights to the abandoned buildings they occupied. No such luck here.  There were isolated squatters movements in the US (mostly centered around groups like ACT UP and Housing Works here in NYC). in 1988, NYC had a huge clash at Tompkins Square Parks during a ‘police riot’ against squatters. But it never got much public attention.

Then came Seattle and the anti-globalization protests of 1999. There were numerous incidents reported of Black Bloc violence, and the violence–not the story of the protesters and why they were in the streets–became the story in the news. The violence of the protests also made some religious organizations shy away from supporting the Jubilee 2000 campaign, an effort to get Western banks to cancel government debt in poor parts of the developing world.

In 1999, I wrote a play about the WTO and Seattle and what the debt was about. A monologue play called ON THE GRID, it was a WTO executive laying out all the dirty laundry about globalization to a class of newly-minted ‘aid professionals’. We got invited to take the play to the anti WTO events in Prague, Czech Republic in 2000. I had other things going on, so my actor (we’ll call him ‘Ben’) agreed to go on his own. the Prague folks were doing serious arts outreach as a way of counteracting the meme of the black bloc.

Funny thing….
So Ben (oops, I mean ‘Ben’)takes off from JFK as a performing artist with gigs lined up. He lands in Prague as a terrorist–the state cited the Black Bloc as the reason to shut down all cultural outreach by the protesters. He ended up doing ON THE GRID in front of an enthusiastic crowd in an abandoned tractor factory–hundreds of people in the audience. But when he came back (and of course the black bloc provided the right pictures for world media), he said ‘everything the media said about Black Bloc is a lie’. He felt that the window-breakers were a false flag, put in place to make violence the story.
So that’s my black bloc story. Is the part about the government backing the Black bloc true? I don’t know. I wasn’t there. But I DO know that Black bloc’s appearance in Prague in 2000 was used as a justification to blow away any chance at a counter-narrative to the WTO. And that sure didn’t help our side.
From what I’m reading,  James Holmes is a deeply disturbed individual, in the mold of Jared  Lee Loughner (the man who shot Gabby Giffords) or Seung-Hui Cho, the young shooter in the Virginia Tech massacre. The right wing blogosphere has been quiet so far today about ‘connections’ between Holmes and Occupy. I’m hoping that means there’s no connection that can be reasonably drawn between James Holmes and the Occupy movement. But folks within the movement should understand that the people in power are dying to prove some sort of link between Occupiers and violence. And if we get too casual about this, if we don’t condemn violence on our side, well… do I need to say it?

One comment

  1. [...] brings me back to my point about the Black Bloc that I made last week. My guess is that once officialdom gets a conviction against Occupy members for a terrorism charge, [...]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: